rdmsm4x-changelog-20260903-0127-tyrell-build13-release-rereview

Tyrell Build 13 release rereview

Completed an independent read-only release rereview of the amended Build 13 dirty diff and issued a NO-GO because the accepted-prior transaction is not retry-safe or complete-bundle-bound and some outer menu-bar restoration failures remain suppressed.

Scope

Host: rdmsm4x
Project worktree reviewed: /Users/richh/dev/_worktrees/tyrell-build18-chat-catalog-20260902
HEAD: 42277bcf045b3e9d6b93ac2ab98355db08c89d56
Frozen diff SHA-256: 39d3d88a83d574374776fe3283a12712b58d774438891552df69d9a650b34a12
Review artifact: /Users/richh/dev/_handoff/tyrell-build13-release-rereview-20260903.md
Review artifact SHA-256: 2d6fa0b18d2eea7feb51114a442e90277d4425e9a46f570c112eb545ace44bb2

Files changed by this review

/Users/richh/dev/_handoff/tyrell-build13-release-rereview-20260903.md
/Users/richh/dev/LLM/Claude/changelogs/rdmsm4x-changelog-20260903-0127-tyrell-build13-release-rereview.md

No Tyrell source file or installed runtime was edited.

Verification

Syntax checked the five release scripts: exit 0.
Ran five focused script contracts: all exit 0.
Ran MeterSettingsStoreTests: exit 0, nine tests selected.
Confirmed git diff --check clean.
Reconfirmed frozen dirty diff SHA-256.
Reviewed lead-provided full Swift evidence: 669/669 passed.
Reviewed lead-provided disposable iOS 27 evidence: 73/73 passed.

Release result

NO-GO for canary/fleet deployment.
P1: already-candidate retry fails when the fleet caller provides the prior accepted hash.
P1: accepted-current hash covers the foreground executable, not the complete signed app identity.
P2: several outer paths suppress failure to restore the prior menu-bar job.
P2: nested helper Team/runtime/requirement is not fully gated before outer app mutation.

Rollback

This review changed documentation only. Remove the two files listed above if the record itself must be withdrawn; no product or runtime rollback is needed.

Outstanding owner action

Correct the release-transaction findings, rerun the source review, then rebuild/sign and use rdmbair15m5 for the designated canary before broader deployment.