rdmsm4x-changelog-20260903-0156-tyrell-build13-release-rereview-v3
Tyrell Build 13 release rereview v3
Completed an independent read-only release gate against the explicitly frozen Build 13 dirty diff and found one remaining fail-open TyrellBar acceptance defect, so the result is NO-GO.
- Scope: local
rdmsm4xreview only; no remote hosts, app runtime, signing identity, or deployment changed. - Source reviewed:
/Users/richh/dev/_worktrees/tyrell-build18-chat-catalog-20260902at base HEAD42277bcf045b3e9d6b93ac2ab98355db08c89d56, dirty diff SHA-2562af2b8b3d73becfccda78c3dfaa3b58a14f94e201aeec2d9c62a353bad88d78f. - File added:
/Users/richh/dev/_handoff/tyrell-build13-release-rereview-v3-20260903.md(SHA-256574caea58b6bf92d735167ae3d1154ba8480a8ad7b103ce93753c6bb6594e3bd). - Project files touched by reviewer: none.
- Validation: six release scripts passed
zsh -n; all eight script contracts passed;git diff --checkpassed; supplied 669/669 Swift log hash verified asf8a21b5ae0519bc370931efca21c7d182c9477bf6a64ae5c2104e0e39d46f6ce. - Finding: the final TyrellBar success path validates one exact-path process and the expected launchd program, but does not require the launchd PID to own that process. It can falsely report success for an orphan/manual helper. Standalone runtime/designated-requirement checks and executable outer rollback fault coverage are also documented as P2 gaps.
- Undo: remove only the added handoff report and this changelog file. No source or runtime rollback is required.
- Outstanding owner action: bind final helper process PID to the loaded LaunchAgent PID, add absent/mismatched PID fault cases, and request another independent release review before canary.
- Apple Notes: pending because this reviewer runs under the
Backgroundlaunchd manager and cannot safely send GUI AppleEvents.