rdmsm4x-changelog-20260903-0339-tyrell-build13-stale-app-archive-rereview-v2
Independent v2 release review confirmed the original Tyrell stale-copy archive blockers were repaired but found two final receipt-verification blockers.
Scope
- Host:
rdmsm4x - Reviewed worktree:
/Users/richh/dev/_worktrees/tyrell-build18-chat-catalog-20260902 - Reviewed only the frozen three-file stale-app archive transaction at
HEAD
bf4453d68767bd5e236ba86df5b71e26b57ff64c. - No project source, app copy, archive, LaunchServices record, process, API, deployment, or runtime was changed by the review.
Created files
/Users/richh/dev/_handoff/tyrell-build13-stale-app-archive-rereview-v2-20260903.md/Users/richh/dev/LLM/Claude/changelogs/rdmsm4x-changelog-20260903-0339-tyrell-build13-stale-app-archive-rereview-v2.md
Frozen evidence
- Synthetic no-index patch SHA-256:
19e68376c8407528f621e74828ed1e7bd0bebf824e169a50b5165b7bacd571ef - Archive script SHA-256:
2c19085b38b2bb1c31640a22850a1745b7178ea6ee8421c479f46bfa3f19ba0d - Transaction library SHA-256:
45dc033a05cbf6794c154773c467e09bd3934b077e8fb087e3ff03d3662957a1 - Executable contract SHA-256:
60e04c501ef8a20f30d45de9b9429dcd9fe6e1e4c33cd802129bfa9d0b1257f2 - Review report SHA-256:
d6a3e64ae547f4d7fbdf9a16863b27ad5e057feabd8d66f0259b31e9daecaac2 - Syntax and all nine release contracts passed; no-index whitespace checks had no diagnostics.
Result
- Verdict: NO-GO for one
rdmbair15m5archive canary. - All first-review P1 findings were materially closed.
- Remaining P1: completion is published before independent verification; a rejected completion diverts all retries away from resume reconciliation.
- Remaining P1:
--verifydoes not validate finalmanifest.tsvorarchived-files.sha256and can reportalready_verifiedafter either audit artifact is missing or corrupt. - P2: later restoration does not re-prove the original parent remains on the archive volume.
- P2: crashes before complete transaction/item journal publication can wedge a safe pre-mutation state.
Undo
- Remove only the two review-record files listed above if created in error. No product/runtime rollback is applicable.
Outstanding owner action
- Correct both P1 receipt-verification defects and add executable post-completion failure plus missing/corrupt final-manifest tests before another canary rereview.